A while back I was a little shocked by Donald Trump’s pronouncement that the only way he could lose Pennsylvania was if the election was rigged. I say a little shocked because, let’s face it, we’re rapidly becoming inured to any new outrage. I guess he feels this way because of the crowds at his rallies. Fact is, there’s a difference between rallyers and voters. Clearly this is something the whole Trump clan doesn’t understand. Remember when a couple of his own kids didn’t get registered in time to vote for dear old dad in the primary? This had nothing to do voter id, or any other thing that Trump endorses to prevent voter fraud. It was purely personal oversight—something most people acknowledge as a more prevalent issue than people voting multiple times. But nonetheless, it’s a mistake a real “voter” would never make.
At its best, political rallies take you back to high school pep rallies. (Or as we call them in my neck of the woods “thuses”—for raising enthusiasm.) During a large portion of the four decades I taught, our football coach was Bob DeLorenzo, affectionately known as Big D. Bob was probably the most persuasive speaker I’ve ever encountered. He was not a shouter, but he had the emotion and modulation of a Shakespearean star. In fact, one of my colleagues had him come in and perform the “to be, or not to be” soliloquy every time she taught Hamlet.
Those Friday afternoon hours of frenzy prepped players and fans alike for the game that night. But Big D was a teacher as much as a coach. Of course he loved to win and had plenty of kids go on to play college ball, a couple even had a shot at the pros. But, he knew that for most of that squad their last high school game was their football swan song. They would go on to become husbands and dads, teachers, salesmen, hospital workers, and city cops—contributing members of society who had internalized those values of teamwork, dedication, discipline and hard work. Pep rallies were a success if they made those attending leave united to do good work.
At their worst, rallies have become the death metal mosh pits of American politics—loud, angry, aggressive, and nihilistic. The desire to go out and crack some heads and roust some immigrants is not what I consider good work.
But good or bad, rallies take you back to your teen years. I suppose if you’re one of those people who believes the myth that those four years of high school were the best years of your life, this might be making America great again. But for people more comfortable in their adult status, high school was an interesting part of your past, but you don’t want to live there.
I have never really liked crowds, and the older I get, the less I like them. My friends know that I’m only half kidding when I say I’ve got about a three hour window of sociability. The bigger the crowd, the narrower the window. I can count on one hand the number of rallies I’ve been to, but I vote with dogged regularity. Never missed voting in any election since 1972. And for every rallyer, there are at least a dozen voters. We’re not cheering and clapping. We’re sitting at home, watching debates, reading the editorials, contemplating the candidates. And guess what? Come November, our votes count just as much. No rigging. Just one person, one vote. And that’s a truly honest election. But what do I know? I’m just a spinster with cats.